Could Britain be the next Iceland?
I read with great interest a transcript of Mario Innecco’s[1] musings related to the Sterling Gilt ‘doom loop’, and whether the recent sharp rises in Gilt yields could accelerate into another Sterling crisis. Our politicians point the finger of blame at inflationary energy price rises, but this does not explain Sterling’s yield premium needed to entice investors to fund the country’s growing mountain of debt. Even France, an economy arguably in worse shape than the UK’s, enjoys far lower borrowing costs. The Gilt market refers to this as a ‘moron’ premium: this is the amount of additional interest required to persuade investors to buy the debt of a country with an administration that ignores economic realities and, in the case of the UK, shows no appetite to control spending.
In terms of its size and a strong finance sector, the UK is very different to Iceland. However, as Jim Sinclair and Peter Carlin point out in A Pocket Book of Gold, when a heavily indebted country fails to refinance its debt while interest rates are low, the potential for a currency collapse increases if financing costs then rise sharply. Iceland’s currency collapse in 2008 was not an untypical example. A country whose population enjoyed a high standard of living financed in the local currency, suffered the consequences of a 50% depreciation of the Icelandic Krona. There followed a catastrophic fall in living standards and the destruction of domestic asset values and savings. This doubling of the cost of survival provides a perfect example of inflation as a currency event.
A Gilt market ‘doom loop’ also threatens a serious currency event. This situation has been creeping up on the UK for over a decade, but I fear we could be nearing the cusp of something significant. A Pocket Book of Gold was written in 2010 when the UK’s national debt was £500 billion. It has since quintupled to £2.7 trillion, representing an estimated 94% of GDP.
In 2008, UK pension funds and insurers held 46% of the entire £500 billion stock of government debt, while the Bank of England did not own any Gilts at all. Now, UK pensions and insurers hold a mere 20%, foreign investors 34%, and the Bank of England now owns 17% of all Gilts in issue. Rising energy prices have provided the trigger for the recent explosion in Sterling debt yields, with the economy in no condition to withstand an arguably self-inflicted risk for a country that imports 54% of its diesel fuel.
The pound is already showing early signs of trouble, but could Sterling be on its way back to Dollar parity? The spike in UK Gilt yields started after a period of artificial interest rate suppression during Covid, when the Bank bought debt with newly created money, saving the financial system for the second time in fifteen years. But, in the process, effectively bankrupting the country. Since the post Pandemic interest rate rises, longer dated Gilt prices had remained relatively stable until the attacks on Iran in early March of this year, since when they have risen by one full percentage point to 5.3% today. With over one-third of all Gilts now owned by foreign investors, a buyer’s strike could mean that rates have further to rise, particularly after Budget on 28 October, when the UK’s ‘moron premium’ could widen further.
In all likelihood the Bank will be forced to intervene again and support debt markets to entice investors unwilling to fund even higher borrowing. The risk is that the wider economy suffers. Homeowners and businesses are already wrestling with rising taxes and energy costs. The currency will continue to fall if the economy is considered too fragile to withstand the rate rises required to support Sterling and choke off inflation.
Gilt yields and the Pound are the canaries in the coal mine. Sterling having reached a 2026 high of $1.3623 as recently as August is unlikely to find that $1.30 provides the bottom. The UK is at the mercy of overseas investors and the Bank of England’s willingness to print money. If confidence erodes further, although we are unlikely to see an immediate Icelandic 50% currency crash, in the short term a 10% to 20% fall seems quite possible, and who knows how much further Sterling can fall over the ensuing months if the UK’s debt situation deteriorates further.
[1] Mario Innecco is a financial markets analyst, macroeconomics commentator, and precious metals expert. He specialises in exchange-traded derivatives, government bonds, and interest rates, drawing on over 25 years of professional experience within the City of London's financial sector. Innecco's financial career includes working in private banking in Geneva and institutional derivatives brokerage in London for major firms such as Citigroup and ABN AMRO. Having spent his early life in Brazil during the hyperinflationary period of the 1970-80s and 1980s, Innecco developed a foundational interest in monetary instability.
About the author
Jo Welman had a career in the City spanning 45 years and worked in a wide variety of financial sectors. After graduating from Exeter University in 1979 with a degree in economics, Jo spent ten years at Baring Asset Management where he managed a range of UK and US pension funds and unit trusts, investing across multiple sectors including bonds, international equities, commercial and residential property and private equity.
In 1989 Jo became Managing Director of merchant bank Rea Brothers’ institutional and private wealth investment management division. Over the following decade Jo launched a series of specialist investment trusts and funds in a variety of industry and property sectors, before forming a joint venture with reinsurance broker Benfields (now Aon Benfield) and raising one of the first limited liability corporate capital vehicles for the Lloyds insurance market in 1993. As part of his long-standing involvement in the insurance industry, Jo co-founded the Benfield Re-Insurance Investment Trust plc (Brit) in 1995. Following the sale of Rea to Close Brothers in 1999 Jo became Chairman of Brit Insurance Holdings Plc and in 2001, in partnership with Brit and Benfields, he co-founded specialist asset management firm, EPIC Investment Partners (EPIC).
Jo continues to provide corporate finance and investment advice to entrepreneurs and private investors. He sits on the board as a non-executive director of ARK Syndicate Underwriting.
“Feet up by the pool”
Jo does not receive any remuneration for his EPIC commentary. Instead, EPIC is pleased to promote the latest edition of his book “Feet up by the pool”.
Profits from sales of the book go to The Money Charity, a charity that shares Jo’s objective to help fill in some of the worrying gaps in the school curriculum. These omissions leave many young adults lacking in the financial awareness that they need to survive in a world where they will rely on their own savings if they are ever to stop working. Even if they earn the right to a full State Pension, today this amount hardly covers council tax and utility bills, and so they need to save and build up a sum of capital amounting to around twenty times their desired retirement income. A frightening number.
As Jo eloquently says, “If we can do our bit to raise awareness of the impending UK saving and pensions crisis, the exercise will have been worthwhile.”