The Jobless Claims See-Saw: What Lies Beneath the Ups and Downs
For nearly six months, weekly changes in continuing jobless claims have alternated consistently—rising one week, falling the next—for 24 consecutive weeks. The likelihood of such a precise pattern emerging randomly is extraordinarily slim, approximately 8.4 million to 1, strongly suggesting data quirks rather than genuine economic movements.
Continuing claims offer critical insights into labour market health, reflecting how swiftly unemployed individuals secure new employment. While regular fluctuations are normal, this remarkable alternation signals statistical anomalies more than actual shifts in employment conditions.
We attribute this unusual pattern primarily to flawed seasonal adjustment methods, designed to smooth predictable variations in hiring, such as holiday or seasonal cycles. Administrative factors—like staggered filing schedules or delayed reporting from certain states—could introduce consistent week-to-week volatility unrelated to underlying economic fundamentals. If filing schedules were to change, the previous seasonal adjustments would introduce this saw-tooth pattern in the data. We can’t be certain, but this seems the most likely explanation.
Yet beneath these statistical irregularities lies an important and genuine trend: continuing claims have been steadily edging upward, approaching their highest levels since late 2021. This increase indicates unemployed workers are facing longer job searches, a reality seemingly at odds with robust payroll employment figures. Such divergence suggests increasing friction and caution among employers, nuances not immediately apparent in headline job data.
Initial unemployment claims remain relatively low, reflecting minimal mass layoffs. However, the gradual rise in continuing claims highlights subtle but real softening in labour market conditions. Employers appear increasingly cautious, resulting in slower hiring and longer periods of unemployment for jobseekers.
In our view, the upward drift in continuing claims points to genuine but modest weakening in labour market dynamics. Should this trend persist, it could negatively affect consumer spending and corporate profitability, thereby influencing monetary policy considerations. Conversely, easing labour market tightness could help moderate inflationary pressures, potentially allowing the Federal Reserve greater flexibility in its policy approach.
Although the alternating weekly pattern is likely a statistical curiosity, it underscores the necessity of cautious data interpretation. By focussing on multi-week averages we get a clearer picture of the trend than the more volatile weekly data. Ultimately, the gradual but persistent rise in continuing claims is an early sign of potential economic softening that warrants careful attention in the months ahead.
If you would like to receive The Daily Update to your inbox, please email markets@epicip.com or click the link below.