When Vacancies Vanish, Payrolls Follow
Usually, on the first Friday of the month, markets would be preparing for the US non-farm payrolls report. This month it has been postponed. The Bureau of Labor Statistics has moved the January Employment Situation release from 6 February to Wednesday, 11 February, following a brief lapse in federal funding. The delay is procedural, but it comes at a moment when confidence in the labour market narrative is already being tested.
For much of the past two years, any cooling in employment data was framed as orderly and reassuring. “Normalisation” became the default explanation, suggesting that excesses from the post-pandemic boom were being worked off without lasting damage. From early 2026, that interpretation is becoming harder to defend. The adjustment from the 2022 peak to current conditions looks less like a smooth descent and more like a sustained erosion in labour demand that was visible earlier than many were prepared to acknowledge.
At the height of the reopening surge, labour demand reached levels without modern precedent. Job openings peaked at just over 12mn in early 2022, according to the JOLTS survey, leaving close to two vacancies for every unemployed worker. Bargaining power shifted decisively towards labour, job switching accelerated and firms competed aggressively for staff. Policymakers accepted that such an imbalance could not persist.
When vacancies began to fall through 2023 and into 2024, the initial response was relief. Payroll growth remained positive, unemployment stayed low and the decline in openings was taken as evidence that tighter policy was working as intended. Excess demand, it was argued, was being removed without job losses.
That interpretation has become harder to sustain as the scale and persistence of the decline have become clearer. By the end of last year, job openings had fallen to around 6.5 million, more than 5 million below their peak and below their pre-pandemic trend. What was first described as adjustment now looks increasingly like a contraction in hiring appetite itself.
This matters because it runs against how labour data are usually read. Payrolls dominate attention, while vacancies are treated as secondary. Yet hiring intent typically turns before employment does. Firms slow expansion plans first and only cut jobs later. On that basis, the collapse in vacancies points to a weakening in labour demand that is more fundamental than headline employment figures alone suggest.
Recent data points are sharpening that concern. Private-sector job growth has slowed materially, following a year in which hiring was already running at roughly half the pace of the year before. The sectoral breakdown is telling. Professional services, finance and parts of manufacturing are retrenching. Healthcare remains the main source of private-sector job growth, driven largely by demographics rather than cyclical confidence. Without it, overall momentum would be close to flat.
The quits rate reinforces the picture. Having peaked above 3 per cent in 2022, it has declined steadily and now sits close to levels last seen during the pandemic. Workers are less confident about moving. Reduced mobility weakens wage dynamics and weighs on household confidence, shifting the labour market from expansion towards preservation.
For the Federal Reserve, this alters the balance of risks. Job openings are now at levels historically associated with late-cycle slowdowns. The labour market is not collapsing, but it is more fragile than payrolls alone suggest. The delayed January report is unlikely to alter the trend already visible in JOLTS. When it arrives on 11 February, it will test whether that weakness in intent is beginning to appear in employment itself.
Vacancies capture ambition. When ambition fades, outcomes tend to follow with a lag. The US labour market is no longer overheating, but nor is it settling smoothly into balance. The next payrolls report will show whether that loss of intent is finally reaching the headline numbers.
If you would like to receive The Daily Update to your inbox, please email markets@epicip.com or click the link below.